What are some good books to read after harry potter. Parts of lord of the rings can be found in other text, just like harry potter probably has parts that are reminiscent of lord of the rings. Similarities between harry potter and the lord of the rings a poll by jamesh5. For readers who want books to read after harry potter which feature strong women, pullmans works are a great choice. Rowlings harry potter world are fairly superficial, according to rowling herself. Both harry potter and lord of the rings are series of books that have gained much fame and popularity. Was harry potter inspired by the lord of the rings.
Tolkien, for instance, intended the lord of the rings to be the first big ass volume of a twovolume set the second being the equally big ass the silmarillion, as well as the sequel to the hobbit. The actors who played the protagonists even looked similar. Nov 26, 2010 the similarities between the potter and lotr universes. Similarities between harry potter and the lord of the. The first in a series abut a young wizard finding his place in the magical world. There are several parallels, such as elves, dwarfs, wizards, goblins, trolls, magic. I recently had the opportunity to speak with richard about his book. Entertainment editors top 5 books minus harry potter. Similarities between harry potter and lord of the rings by eric s. The similarities between the potter and lotr universes mtv. However, i do feel that tolkien kind of rips off harry potter in many ways.
But if you never actually read those books, like the great gatsby or catcher in the rye, now would be a great time to read them. Like the harry potter movies, the lord of the rings movies engaged lots of people who hadnt read the books. Therefore, do not waste your time criticizing my lack of information mentioned or not mentioned. Harry and his friends practice the magic arts, which is an abomination to god. The students including harry at the school are not human children learning magic, but wizards. Just like harry potter, the hunger games based on a book trilogy follows teens fighting for their lives in order to right the wrongs of the adults that came before them. Legend has it that the reallife flamel discovered the secret to eternal life. There are no movies like harry potter and the lord of the rings. Come in to read stories and fanfics that span multiple fandoms in the harry potter and lord of the rings universe. Influence as i mentioned above, the lord of the rings has influenced every fantasy novel since, and that includes the harry potter books. This book has been celebrated for its unique magic system and inventive forms of narration. Buying sensational books is like feeding your child with spoons of added sugar, whiting wrote, heaps of it. These highly recommended, highly addicting, cantputemdown stories of adventure and fantasy will lift kids out of the postharry potter doldrums.
The first of these is ron weasley, who devolves into a thoroughly unlikeable character in later books. Rowlings wizarding world into other enchanted literary universes, theres no shortage of books like harry potter. The best books to read if you love harry potter time. Adults who are in mourning over the end need not fear. There are like thousands of books available on the subject and theme of fantasy and fiction. All right, so i wanted to see how many of you like harry potter, how many the lord of the rings, and also which characters you prefer. Additionally, harry potter has seven books in its series, whereas lord of the rings has only three. Voldemort, in harry potter had tried to kill harry as a baby and due to that some of his powers have been given to harry himself. Difference between harry potter and lord of the rings. Over 4000 pages of harry potter and his world, including all 7 books.
The mentor of both books were wizards with long white beards. I would like to begin by describing the major differences in harry potter and the lord of the rings. The 10 most magical books to read if you love harry potter. Maybe youll never find a book better than harry potter, but that. Aug 26, 2019 im sure you have other ideas for books like lord of the rings id honestly love to hear them. Jul 22, 2019 though its easy to get lost somewhere between the shire and mordor, there is indeed more to fantasy fiction than hobbits, lords, and their rings. Comparison between lord of the rings and harry potter. Overall, though, much as lotr is about middleearth, the harry potter books are about their characters. It may be nearly sixty years since the last the lord of the rings book was published, but j. The 5 books are all written in the present day and have the wonder and amazement that those other series do but have a modern day backdrop. Though its easy to get lost somewhere between the shire and mordor, there is indeed more to fantasy fiction than hobbits, lords, and their rings. In fact, harry potter and lotr are the first listed in tvtropes warning. This is similar to the lord of the rings in that a kind of power comes with the ring that has been passed on from the maker of the ring. Did harry potter really steal all these story ideas.
Please do not let your children read the harry potter books. Similarities between harry potter and lord of the rings. What you need to know about fantasy books and movies, he discusses why the j. Imdb user believed lord of the rings ripped off harry.
Jun 27, 2017 however, it happens sometimes that popular movies that win the hearts of millions of people all over the world have some similarities. Lord of the rings, harry potter, chronicles of narnia, his dark materials. Billed as a grownup harry potter, this adult novel follows brooklyn teenager quentin coldwater to brakebills academy for an education in sorcery and romance and general college debauchery. Lord of the rings is not just a book series but a marvelous literature creation by j. Harry potter and lord of the rings crossover fanfiction archive with over 783 stories. Because both harry potter and lord of the rings borrow from folklore and mythology, they would necessarily share many elements. Harry potter and lord of the rings crossover fanfiction. Harry potter vs lord of the rings books not movies. Comparing harry potter with the lord of the rings essay sample. Like tolkiens elves, they can be mistaken for humans, they can marry humans and have children with. Books similar to harry potter and the lord of the rings. I like both lord of the rings and harry potter, but lord of the rings is much better. All seven ebooks in the multiaward winning, internationally bestselling harry potter series.
Weve gathered 14 movies like harry potter many of which were also adapted from books that will deliver exactly the right dose of magic. Sep 20, 2018 from the golden compass to city of bones, heres time s take on the 10 most magical books to read if you love harry potter. After graduation, quentin moves back to new york with his magical friends but is unimpressed with his mystical lifeuntil he learns that fillory, the. The series of worst witch books skews younger and tends to the lighter side of magic than the harry potter books. His publisher sensibly refused to do this, instead dividing up lotr into three books. Mar 11, 2015 the books of magic makes the lord of the rings, the avengers, harry potter, and even twilight all look like entries in the same broad genre of tweensuperhero fantasy, in which someone. This one is probably on every books like harry potter list around, but its for good reason. The protagonist, katniss everdeen, competes in the nation of panems hunger games, a nationally televised event that sees her pitted against children of the nation as they fight to the death to be the games sole survivor. While sometimes the movies dragged due to the excessive amount of walking, they followed the books extremely well we arent talking about the hobbit here because those did not follow the book well at all. Take, for example, two most famous film series of the 2000s harry potter and the lord of the rings. Reasons lord of the rings is better than harry potter.
Magical creatures, wizards, adventure and a mission to save the world is something which is common between all these books like lord of the rings here. Written by karen wynn fonstad, the atlas of middleearth describes the realms tolkien created in the hobbit, the lord of the rings, and the silmarillion. After all, think how upset hermione would be to know that you havent been reading more books. A lot has been made of similarities between these two works of fiction over the years especially on the internet below is a list of the most noted upon similarities, which do you think is the most remarkable. Tolkiens the lord of the rings became the gold standard of fantasy. All of the works the multivolume book series and the two movies display a clear conflict between good and evil, with good ultimately triumphing, and focus on the powers of love, loyalty, goodness, and truth in opposition to selfishness, greed, and exploitation. Tolkiens fantasy novels and want to know more about the worlds hes created, you may enjoy this book. When you take the time to cherrypick specific aspects, these two books can seem very similar. Maybe youll never find a book better than harry potter, but that doesnt mean you cant enjoy reading other novels about magic, friendship. I found his dark materials, after someone recommending me them since i. This is the first abanes work i have read and i am quite delighted by his depth of research and care for the very influential art forms of literature and visual media. May 17, 2016 i am a huge fan of both lord of the rings and harry potter. The lord of the rings trilogy and harry potter series are works of fantasy.
What are other movies like harry potter and the lord of. Children will come to believe they can cast spells or do other things to solve their problems when the only one who can solve their problems is jesus christ. I was not a terribly immediate fan of the lord of the rings series, but i do like the books and movies nonetheless. I dont own harry potter nor do i own lord of the rings. Aug 14, 2010 the first book is called the eye of the world. Ring child rewrite living lightning chapter one just harry. May 21, 2019 but while its hardand perhaps a bit unfairto compare any story to the tale of the boy who lived, there are still plenty of narratives out there to give you a similar sense of escape. I strongly believe that books channeling fantasy and fiction are really super engrossing. Dartthornton s bestselling fantasy creates a tale of magic and adventure that has been praised as a beautifully spun fantasy and even compared to the lord of the rings by grand master of science fiction, andre norton. Ive deliberately avoided harry potter, lord of the rings and things you may or may not have read in high school, because thats boring and a cop out.
Oct 19, 2015 it seems impossible to think that anything could compare, but if you look hard enough, there are books we can read as adults that have some of the same elements as our beloved harry potter. Is the lord of the rings series similar to harry potter. Raia aspires to be like hanalea, the legendary warrior queen who killed the demon king and saved the world. Im kind of surprised by a few popular series that didnt make this list. For those who have either never read harry potter and lord of the rings, or lack the silly elephantine memory to categorize the. Rather than epic fantasy, the book belongs to the genre of science fiction but of course there are elements of adventure and amazing incidents which keeps the reader high on excitement throughout. Harry potter is a bildungsroman, a coming of age novel which spans harry s and his friends growing up. A convicted murderer, sirius black, has broken out of azkaban prison, and it seems hes after harry. This book contains a pretty in depth comparison of three influential series of harry potter, lord of the rings, and narnia however the book as a whole does not fully revolve around these works alone. In his book, harry potter, narnia, and the lord of the rings. Longbottom this word is used as the last name for one of the side characters in harry potter while in lord of rings its used as a town name and as the name for the best pipe weed. And when we cherrypick the ones that seem to match, it makes it feel like their structure is similar, when in fact its just random points of congruence.
However, i first read lotr as a young teen and harry potter as a middleaged guy, so that may color my opinions harry potter is definitely the easier read, but i cared much more for the fantastic world and characters that tolkien made. There are more books like lord of the rings which you would surely like to read if fantasy and adventure is your forte. The whole reason that he wrote it was that he felt that why couldnt the lord of the rings take place in present day or why did harry potter have to appear in a fictional castle. There are 25 questions and a butterbeerbreak in the middle. The top ten reasons lord of the rings is better than harry potter. Nov 27, 20 similarities between harry potter and lord of the rings by eric s. Continue reading comparing harry potter with the lord of the rings. If you are fan of either series please take the survey, though i do warn you it is rather long. Are there any books like lord of the rings, the chronicles of narnia, harry potter, and the hitchhikers guide to the galaxy. Given that harry and the gang are adults now, were recommending novels that cater to the readers who matured right alongside themthink books like harry potter, but for adults. They are an entirely different species, similar to elves like legolas in the lord of the rings but without pointy ears. Its sort of like harry potter meets lord of the rings. Nov 10, 2005 weeping willow is featured more in harry potter. Something closer to harry potter that i would recommend would be the inkheart series.
This is my first lord of the rings and harry potter crossover and im so excited for this. Like harry potter, they are considered childrens books but are much darker and complex than most books for children. I find lord of the rings far superior to harry potter. Lord of the rings is older and was published in 1954 by j. Please put on and vote on any books that you think harry potter fans would like. The books use fantasy to enrich the settings, characters, and plot. Harry potter is a fantasy series that is similar to the lord of the rings in many ways. Twins sophie and josh find out the legend is true when they become entangled in a battle for the book of abraham the mage.
This story will take you on a magical adventure just like harry potter does. If youve never read the lord of the rings, youre going to find so many plot and character similarities to harry potter. Thats why my wife, a grown woman, shed actual tears when fred weasley was killed, and why the books are named after the main hero, as opposed to lotr, which is named after the main villain. Fantasy and your family takes you on a fascinating tour of not only the lord of the rings and harry potter, but also of our society s obsession with modern magick. Harry potter fans may remember nicholas flamel from his appearance in harry potter and the sorcerers stone. This story stands firmly on its own two feet, and fits into a list of books like lord of the rings where the appeal is the unlikely hero. When you think of reading phenomena, most likely harry potter and lord of the rings come to mind as two of the biggest series in the recent literature. Harry talking through his mind thoughts harry laid curled up looking at the prison door with dead eyes. Events of the first movie are set in presentday britain, while the latter takes place in a fantasy world of middleearth.
Rowlings harry potter series is vastly different from the christianbased works of c. As of this writing, two of these nooks have been posted to youtube by the propping block, with one dedicated to the lord of the rings and the other to harry potter. The charlie bone series by jenny nimmo and the septimus heap magyk series by angie sage. Are there any books like lord of the rings, the chronicles. Dragonsong is another one in the list of alternative lord of the rings books on amazon and it is the first book from the trilogy harper hall. The best books to read for fans of lord of the rings book. Harry potter is focused on a much more realworld setting and the characters are pretty much all relatable humans. Books similar to the lord of the rings the lord of the. However, it wasnt until the books came to movies that the rivalry between the two worlds, or fandoms, really began. The lord of the rings movies tell the story of frodo baggins, who, like harry, is an unlikely hero. Im going to assume you are probably already familiar with books such as lord of the rings and game of thrones, but you might consider checking out more books like harry potter to read next if you loved j. Published november 27, 20 updated january 11, 2017 because harry can go there and back again, too. When harry potter and the halfblood prince opens, the war against voldemort has. Strong, complex female characters, a good trioquartet of friends, and.
Can reading harry potter, the hunger games and the lord of the rings. The lord of the rings takes place in a high fantasy world. What are the best books to read if you are a fan of lord of the rings. The insight and ingenuity of it and the aweinspiring, strong characters resonates brilliantly even. Both series were recommended to me on amazon after i closed the last harry potter book and needed a new fantasy fiction fix. No fantasy film series can compare to those created from the works of visionaries j. Mar 09, 2016 though its easy to get lost somewhere between the shire and mordor, there is indeed more to fantasy fiction than hobbits, lords, and their rings. Here are the best books i read lately, that match your criteria. The series is great, if long, but it is on a similar epic scale as lord of the rings. Are there any books like lord of the rings, the chronicles of narnia. Also, when the characters came to the big screen, there were obvious similarities. This is my personal opinion, so please dont take it too seriously. First, the main character is a boy who has the fate of the world resting on his shoulders, since he is the only one who can defeat the villain, voldemort.
This is the first abanes work i have read and i am quite delighted by his depth of research and care for the very influential art forms of. Tolkien transformed the fantasy genre forever when he debuted his epic tale the hobbit in 1937, further altering the genres state with his subsequent trilogy the lord of the rings. This book includes an indepth look at some of today s fantasy bestsellers and how they compare with each other. Absolutely adore them both, so i thought to myself, wouldnt it be cool to mix the two so this little baby is what i conjured up from my teensy little brain.
What others are there they all have a similar type of feeling, fantasy, magic, other worlds and all the rest of it. The lord of the rings is a classic epic fantasy trilogy which many harry potter readers greatly enjoy. There are barely any kind of allusions to real life. I could spend hours arguing whether sirius blacks death was unnecessary or how frodo wasnt as whiny in the books as he was in the movies.